Cozy Supernatural Mysteries to Curl Up With This Halloween
When Halloween season rolls around, some readers love to dive into the spookiest, most chilling tales they can find while others (myself included) prefer something a bit cozier. If you’re looking for supernatural mysteries with just the right amount of ghostly fun without the nightmares, this list is for you. Grab your favorite blanket, pumpkin spice latte, and let’s explore some delightful cozy mysteries perfect for Halloween!
1. Say I Boo by Morgan Spellman
The Abby Spector Ghost Mysteries, Book 1
If you love a good mystery but want your ghost stories served with a side of warmth and humor, Say I Boo is the perfect read. Abby Spector, a lesbian sleuth with a talent for connecting with spirits, finds herself solving ghostly mysteries alongside an eclectic cast of friends. It’s heartwarming, funny, and filled with just the right amount of supernatural sleuthing to keep you hooked without getting too spooky.
Why you’ll love it: The cozy setting, queer representation, and charming mystery make this the ultimate feel-good ghost story.
2. Secondhand Spirits by Juliet Blackwell
The Witchcraft Mystery Series, Book 1
In this enchanting mystery, Lily Ivory is a vintage clothing shop owner—and a witch. She’s moved to San Francisco hoping to lead a quieter life, but soon finds herself involved in a murder mystery that only magic can solve. With a dash of romance, plenty of supernatural intrigue, and a lovable cast of characters, this series is perfect for Halloween when you want a mystery with charm and a bit of witchy magic.
Why you’ll love it: Witchy vibes, vintage fashion, and a cozy San Francisco setting make it an irresistible October read.
3. Practical Potions and Premeditated Murder by Wren Jones
Sella might have a cozy shop and a snarky feline familiar, but life as a kitchen witch isn't easy when your magical abilities are known more for causing trouble than solving problems. When a murder strikes her town and her best friend is the prime suspect, Sella must rely on her magical potions, her friends, and an unexpected ghostly ally to clear her friend's name. With a bit of help from the ghost of the murdered woman herself, Sella’s quest for justice—and her own redemption—begins.
Why you’ll love it: Charming small-town setting, grumpy talking cat, and a delightful ghostly sidekick—what more could you ask for? This cozy mystery blends witchcraft and sleuthing in a way that’s perfect for readers who love magic and charm in their spooky reads.
4. Murder in G Major by Alexia Gordon
The Gethsemane Brown Mysteries, Book 1
If you’re in the mood for a supernatural mystery with a musical twist, look no further. Gethsemane Brown, a classical musician, finds herself in Ireland, where she’s haunted by the ghost of a famous composer. Together, they set out to solve his murder, which is the only way to clear his name. With its atmospheric Irish setting and witty heroine, this series offers the perfect mix of mystery, music, and ghosts.
Why you’ll love it: Cozy Irish vibes, a strong heroine, and a ghostly partner make this a Halloween treat without the tricks.
5. The Ghost of Granny Apples by Sue Ann Jaffarian
The Ghost of Granny Apples Mysteries, Book 1
Emma Whitecastle never imagined her life would take a supernatural turn, but when the ghost of her great-great-great-grandmother, Ish Reynolds—affectionately known as Granny Apples—appears, things get spooky in a lighthearted way. Granny Apples has unfinished business and enlists Emma’s help to solve a century-old murder. Together, this quirky duo investigates the past while navigating present-day mysteries, mixing humor with heart as they tackle ghosts, family secrets, and long-buried crimes.
Why you’ll love it: The mix of family bonds, humor, and a ghostly sidekick with a lot of personality makes this a perfect read for fans of cozy supernatural mysteries with a dash of historical intrigue.
6. Cemetery Boys by Aiden Thomas
In Cemetery Boys, Yadriel is a young trans brujo determined to prove his true identity to his traditional Latinx family. When he accidentally summons the wrong ghost—a mischievous spirit named Julian—Yadriel finds himself caught up in a thrilling mystery with a supernatural twist. As they work together to uncover the truth behind Julian’s death, their unlikely partnership grows into something more, offering a blend of magic, mystery, and heartwarming moments.
Why you’ll love it: Cemetery Boys weaves together themes of identity, family, and love with a beautifully written, ghostly mystery, making it a must-read for anyone who enjoys heartfelt supernatural stories with queer representation.
Whether you’re in the mood for witches, ghosts, or talking cats, these cozy supernatural mysteries offer the perfect blend of eerie and heartwarming. So, as the nights grow longer and the air grows crisper, grab one of these books, settle in, and let yourself be whisked away into the supernatural—without losing any sleep!
For more cozy supernatural recommendations, be sure to check out my books and follow along on my newsletter.
Happy Halloween!
Top Books for Fans of Haunted House Mysteries
There’s something undeniably alluring about haunted house mysteries—the creaking floorboards, the whispering walls, and the sense of secrets lurking just out of sight. For readers who love the thrill of exploring eerie mansions and uncovering ghostly tales, check out this list of must-read books that capture the essence of these atmospheric stories. Whether you’re after spine-tingling chills or a cozy paranormal mystery, these haunted house novels are sure to keep you on the edge of your seat.
1. The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson
A classic of the genre, The Haunting of Hill House is the quintessential haunted house story. Jackson’s novel follows four characters who spend a summer in a sinister mansion to study its supernatural phenomena. As they delve deeper into the house’s secrets, the line between reality and madness begins to blur. This timeless tale of psychological horror is a must-read for anyone fascinated by haunted houses.
2. Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia
Set in 1950s Mexico, Mexican Gothic is a modern gothic horror novel with a strong female lead. Noemí Taboada travels to the remote High Place mansion to check on her cousin, only to find herself entangled in a web of dark family secrets, eerie visions, and the creeping influence of the house itself. The novel’s lush, atmospheric writing and slow-building suspense make it a haunting read.
3. The Ghosts of Rose Hill by R.M. Romero
In The Ghosts of Rose Hill, Ilana Lopez, a young Jewish Cuban girl, is sent to Prague for the summer, where she discovers a crumbling cemetery and a ghostly violinist trapped in time. As she uncovers the history of the ghost and the dark forces that keep him bound, Ilana must confront ancient magic and modern prejudice. This beautifully written, lyrical novel weaves together elements of history, fantasy, and romance, making it a hauntingly memorable read for fans of haunted house mysteries.
4. Home Before Dark by Riley Sager
In Home Before Dark, Riley Sager delivers a gripping tale that flips between past and present, following Maggie Holt as she returns to Baneberry Hall, the house made infamous by her father’s memoir about their haunted experiences. As Maggie uncovers the truth about what really happened, the lines between fiction and reality blur, leading to shocking revelations. Sager’s novel is a page-turner that’s perfect for those who love a modern twist on haunted house mysteries.
5. Say I Boo by Morgan Spellman
This cozy paranormal mystery features a sapphic part-time magician and her bookish best friend snowed in a haunted estate with a stressed-out wedding party. As she tries to save the wedding from ghostly shenanigans, she must determine which ghosts are friendly and which are out for vengeance. With a loveable diverse cast of characters, Say I Boo offers the perfect blend of cozy mystery and supernatural intrigue for those who love haunted house stories with a modern twist.
6. Starling House by Alix E Harrow
This spooky gothic tale about a haunted house with a dark past blends the paranormal with literary fiction. A young woman would do anything to keep custody of her younger brother and get him safely out of their bleak small town—even taking a job cleaning a mysterious haunted house. Filled with mystery and mysticism, this book is a page turner fulled by the power of imagination, nightmares, and dreams.
These books offer a range of haunted house mysteries, from classic gothic tales to modern paranormal thrillers. Whether you prefer slow-burning suspense or fast-paced scares, these novels will satisfy your craving for eerie, atmospheric reads. So, dim the lights, settle in, and prepare to be haunted by these unforgettable stories.